Early Warning Report hopes to limit new TLD contention sets

by | Oct 23, 2025 | Domain names, Domaining | 0 comments

Platform will provide intelligence about other companies’ application plans before reveal day.

Three .crypto applications fighting each other
Early Warning Report hopes to reduce contention sets.

A big point of discussion about the last round of new top level domain expansion was settling contention sets. If more than one applicant applied for the same string, ICANN encouraged them to decide amongst themselves which applicant would get the domain. This led to private auctions between parties where the losers got paid by the winners.

The optics of these private auctions weren’t always great, and ICANN is concerned that people will apply in the next round with the sole purpose of trying to get paid for withdrawing their applications.

Instead of promoting private resolution like last time, a new rule prohibits this type of activity. Instead, applicants will be offered the chance to switch to a backup TLD, participate in an auction where ICANN retains the proceeds, or withdraw their application for a limited refund.

This prohibition on communication starts once the applied-for strings are revealed by ICANN. The applicant guidebook does not prohibit parties from discussing their plans before then.

A new platform hopes to help applicants avoid costly contention sets, or at least plan accordingly, by sharing application plans before applications are revealed.

Early Warning Report allows potential applicants to submit their planned strings and find out if other participants on the platform also intend to apply for them.

The service will operate in two phases.

In the first phase, before applications are due, prospective applicants can pay $1,000 per string to participate. Four weeks before the application window closes, they will be informed if any other parties submitted the same string. They will also be able to send a message to the other applicant(s). Messaging will be similar to using the Whois contact form; the recipient’s information won’t be shared unless they respond to the message.

The second phase will take place after applications are due but before strings are revealed. This stage will cost $3,000, or $2,000 if the same string was submitted in the pre-application round.

At either of these points, potential applicants with competing strings could decide to team up, trade horses, or do something else to prevent going into contention. (Of course, other companies that haven’t participated in Early Warning Report may apply for the same string, creating a contention set that isn’t apparent until after applications are revealed.)

Early Warning Report is the brainchild of Ray King, who applied for TLDs in the last round, and attorney Marc Trachtenberg. A neutral third party will be used to manage the submissions and string matches.

It’s a clever way to help applicants gain insight and potentially avoid costly string contentions, but it will only work if enough applicants participate. King told Domain Name Wire that it will only go forward if at least 200 strings are submitted.

source

Written by

Related Posts

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.